If you’re considering buying a custom engagement ring but don’t know where to start your search, there’s good news: There are several reputable jewelry retailers that now offer customization online.
Online shopping has become so sophisticated in recent years that almost every element of a ring can be modified with a single click, including essential features such as the gemstone, band, metal, and setting.
While not all jewelry brands allow these specific modifications from their website, this guide will help you choose which custom engagement ring retailer is right for you based on price, return policies, warranties, customer service, and the amount of customization you’re looking for.
Custom engagement ring designers at a glance
| brand | price range | Guarantee | Return | best feature | Appointment |
| blue indigo | Settings start at $700 | Limited- Lifetime Warranty | 30 days return | Creative Studio, Detailed Custom Rings | In-store and virtually |
| increased talent | Settings start at $900 | lifetime warranty | 30 days return | custom engagement rings | virtually |
| fantastic earth | Settings start at $850 | lifetime warranty | 30 Day Returns/Custom designed jewelery is not eligible for returns | Make colored gemstone engagement rings | In-store and virtually |
| VRAI | Settings start at $1000 | lifetime warranty | 30 Day Returns/Custom designed jewelery is not eligible for returns | Wide variety of lab-grown diamond shapes | In-store and virtually |
| Ritani | Settings start at $880 | lifetime warranty | 30 days return | affordable custom engagement rings | virtually |
| Katkim | Rings start at $5800 | 3-year warranty | 7-day returns can be exchanged for store-credit only / Custom designed jewelery is not eligible for returns | Minimal and organic engagement rings | In-store and virtually |
| roen | Rings start at $4780 | 90 day limited warranty | 14 Day Returns / Custom designed jewelery is not eligible for returns | stunning and trendy engagement ring designs | In-store and virtually |
At a Glance: Best Online Custom Engagement Ring Designers
blue indigo: Best for quick and detailed customization
increased talent: Best for lab grown diamonds (adaptation)
Glorious Earth: Best for Modern Engagement Rings
VRAI: Best for Lab Grown Diamonds (Variety)
Ritani: Best for affordable custom ring designs
Katkim: Best for minimal pieces
Roen: Best for luxury engagement rings
blue indigo
The brand earns its spot at the top of the list due to its surprisingly large selection of engagement rings. It has more than 1,500 models ready for shipping. Apart from being a brand with one of the largest reserves of diamonds, Blue Nile also boasts of over 200,000 high quality gemstones.
In addition to Blue Nile offering ring models on their website, the brand also offers the possibility to customize any engagement ring through their Creative Studio feature, and thanks to their design software, you can expect a quick and effective full custom design.
Through the Creative Studio, you can change the head and band, as well as choose your own diamond and metal of the piece. The best part is that you can expect to know exactly what your ring will look like, thanks to detailed renders and videos that let you preview your design.
Best Features
- Wide range of prices, many options for any budget.
- GIA and IGI certification.
- excellent customer service
- Customization Options: Their site has one of the highest levels of customization in engagement rings.
- You control how much you want to spend on the ring, depending on the design you choose.
- Regular discounts on ready-to-ship items.
- High quality renders.
increased talent
If you’re looking for a brand that works exclusively with lab-grown diamonds, Grown Brilliance could be an excellent choice.
The brand offers two different ways to personalize your jewelry; The quickest option is to choose one of their setting options and then decide on the shape and size of the diamond.
Another option is to personalize your ring by choosing customization options. You can expect to write a brief description and send a sketch of the ring you want, and then the design team will contact you. This method takes a little longer, but is more personalized.
Best Features
- Custom engagement rings from scratch.
- Large selection of lab grown diamonds to choose from.
- Different shapes of diamonds grown in the laboratory.
- Different ways to personalize your engagement ring depending on your needs.
fantastic earth
Brilliant Earth is a pioneer of ethical fine jewellery, and since 2012, the brand has been one of the first jewelers to offer lab-grown diamonds. Lab diamonds provide a mining-free alternative while maintaining the same properties as natural diamonds.
Regarding metal extraction: If you’re interested in protecting the environment, you’ll be happy to know that the brand uses recycled and sustainable materials for its pieces.
You can customize your engagement ring by selecting the type of gemstone, metal band style, and additional design elements to create a ring that reflects your personal style.
One of the notable features of the brand is that apart from choosing between natural diamonds or lab-grown diamond options, you can also opt for colored gemstones. This is a huge advantage if you are looking for a custom ring with a colored stone.
Best Features
- Possibility to personalize the engagement ring with colored gemstones.
- Gold and silver were reused in jewelery pieces.
- GIA and IGI certification.
- Both natural and laboratory grown diamonds are available.
- You can make an appointment online or visit the store.
VRAI
VRAI can be best described by the words innovation And luxury. Due to the novelty, its new diamond shapes, you will be able to choose from over 31 different diamond shapes for your engagement ring.
Most brands have exclusive designs that you won’t find anywhere else. The luxury lies in their distinctive designs, which can be seen on many Hollywood stars.
Vrai creates lab-grown diamonds in an effort to reduce their environmental impact as much as possible. If you already know you don’t want natural diamonds in your ring and you’re looking for a different (and innovative) design then this is an excellent choice.
The label offers various customization options for its engagement ring designs and also offers creating your own custom ring by appointment online or in one of their physical stores.
Best Features
- Different shapes of diamonds grown in the laboratory.
- Ethical values.
- Design Innovation.
- Custom engagement rings from scratch.
- On-line in-site appointment.
Ritani
Ritani is known for its affordable fine jewelry. The brand offers a wide variety of engagement rings ready to buy and there are many options for personalized jewellery.
If you want to choose every aspect of your ring, you’ll have the option to go step-by-step and choose the setting, diamond, and ring band. As you customize the ring, you can see the price of the different models you can choose from.
The range of their stone customization is very diverse, allowing you to choose between natural diamonds, lab grown diamonds, colored diamonds or colored gemstones.
Best Features
- Customization options for engagement rings.
- Variety of engagement ring settings.
- GIA and IGI certification.
- Ritani offers payment plans.
- Variety of gems.
- They usually get discounts on ready-to-ship pieces.
progress
If you are considering an engagement ring that is unique, with a different feel from classic rings, then you might want to look into this brand.
CatKim is an LA-based brand that offers engagement rings with minimalist, modern aesthetics and organic shapes. Their designs are very different from classic engagement ring models, and you can personalize them with engraving.
The brand also offers other ways to customize the ring, such as choosing the number of carats of the diamond and the type of metal.
Best Features
- Designer engagement rings.
- Minimal aesthetic and organic look.
- Exclusive design.
- Customization options.
- Consultations are available at the showroom or virtually.
roen
If you are looking for a luxurious and unique engagement ring with a modern touch, Roen is a great jewelry brand to go for.
Roen has many ring designs that are a far cry from the original engagement rings. They can also be selectively customized (they are more limited here: only certain elements of the piece are customizable). You will be able to choose whether the diamond is natural or lab-cut, the metal type, and the cut.
If you want to design your own ring, you can do so, but not through their online store. You need to book an appointment in advance and visit their showroom, where you will choose the gemstone and the design direction of your gemstone.
Best Features
- Amazing and trendy design.
- Modern and minimalist shapes.
- Consultations are available at the showroom or virtually.
Bonus: Clean Origin
clean origin
price range: Settings start at $840
Warranty: lifetime warranty
Return: 60 days return
Clean Origin’s designs exclusively use ethically sourced and conflict-free laboratory-grown and natural diamonds. Clean Origins has a wide variety of engagement rings ready to ship, as well as the option to have your ring custom-made.
Their website lets you choose the diamond for your ring, the setting and the metal. You can also choose between natural or lab-grown diamonds, all of which are certified by the IGI and GIA.
Best Features
- Customization options.
- Lab grown and natural diamonds.
- Different shapes of diamonds.
- GIA and IGI certification.
questions to ask
What details can be added to a custom/personalized ring?
Rings may commonly be engraved with a name, date, or short phrase. Sometimes, you can also add small gems inside the band.
Why Choose a Custom Engagement Ring?
If you want the ring to be even more special or because you can’t find the design you have in mind, you can consider customization.
What are the most commonly used metals in engagement rings?
The most commonly used metals are white gold 18k, yellow gold 18k and platinum.
How long does it take to finish a custom ring?
If you choose to design a ring from scratch, this typically takes two to three months (but this depends on the brand and any delays in the design process).
